
“Doc – Will Smallpox affect other Animals?”
© A.J.
Neumann, D.V.M.
published in The Draft Horse Journal, Summer 2002
The answers to the above questions may surprise the average
reader. The study of the pox family is very interesting and
revealing as to what has happened in the past concerning this
collection of killers.
This family of pox diseases in man and animals are caused
by filtrable viruses and is known as variola which is a Latin
term meaning “speckled.” To classify the variola
virus properly we would place it in the family Poxviridae
and the genus Orthopoxvirus. There are seven viruses listed
in this genus, four of which can infect humans. They are
the viruses of smallpox, cowpox, horsepox and monkeypox.
Smallpox, however, seems to be the only virus in this genus
that readily spreads from human to human.
Variola disease
in man and animals alike runs a very unique pattern, in that
it is first characterized by a rise in temperature. This
is followed by a skin eruption of reddish appearing swellings
called “papules.” These then turn into blister-like
swellings containing fluid called “vesicles.” The
vesicles in turn form into “pustules” which are
the same swellings whereby the fluid they contain is replaced
with pus. This then is the general picture of a pox disease
in man or animals.
To understand about variola infections, let’s first
discuss smallpox.
The origin of smallpox is probably lost in the pages of
prehistoric times. We do know however that it was reported
in Chinese records and described in 1122 B.C. An Arabian
physician Rhazein, gave the very first detailed description
of the disease in the early part of 10th century A.D. The
writer and philosopher Galen described and recorded what
he called a “pesta magna” in the 2nd century
A.D. This “pestilence” is believed to have been
smallpox.
Another widespread epidemic of this horrible disease occurred
during the 6th century and was carried back from Asia Minor
by crusaders to infect the countries and feudal estates of
Western Europe. It spread rapidly and became the scourge
of Europe during the middle ages and down through the 18th
century.
During the 1700s it has been estimated by researchers of
these facts and figures, that some 60 million people died
of it, more than the total deaths of all of the wars which
occurred during this period of time. This disease inspired
more fear and terror in the population of the world at that
time than any other factor.
An English nobleman, Lord Macouley, wrote the following
about 1700: “The smallpox was always present, filling
the churchyard with corpses, tormenting with constant fears
all whom it had not stricken, leaving on those whose lives
it spared the hideous traces of its power, turning the babe
into a changeling at which the mother shuddered, and making
the eyes and cheeks of the betrothed maiden objects of horror
to the lover.”
Smallpox not only killed but it often horribly disfigured
the survivors, as another Englishman wrote in about 1600: “Envious
and foule disease could there not be, one beautie in an age
and free from thee.”
And, so it is known, that the disease smallpox, or variola,
has been the greatest killer of mankind, some 300 million
people, plus an untold number of survivors who were disfigured
and maimed for life. It is difficult for one to comprehend
that in the 18th century almost every living human was exposed
to the great scourge, smallpox.
The first symptoms of smallpox in the human will occur about
10 days after exposure to the virus. They may include all
or some of the following; dizziness, headache, nausea, vomiting,
very high fever, and backache or joint aches. In a day or
two the first red spots, papules, will appear on the body
surface. This rash may spread over the entire body and the
red spots will become filled with fluid. These vesicles or
areas, become very hard as they fill with fluid from the
capillaries. This, in turn, gives the affected areas a “pebbly” appearance
and feel.
The fluid gradually gives way to pus and the pustule is
formed. If the pustules are separated by unaffected skin
the cases are known as “discrete” and these patients
will often survive but pay a high price in facial and body
disfigurement. This form of smallpox is known as “variola
major” and has a 30% mortality rate.
If the pustules join together with no unaffected skin between
them, the patient will often become unrecognizable in 4 or
5 days due to huge swellings of the skin areas of the body.
The nose, throat and mouth may be so filled and swollen with
these pustules that the victim cannot eat, drink or swallow.
The skin on these patients when touched often will slough
off in massive sheets. These people will suffer tremendously
and many will die in 10 to 14 days. Medical people call these
cases “confluent pox.”
Another form of smallpox, which will kill 75% of its victims,
is known as “flat” pox. In this smallpox entity
the pustules never rise above the skin level.
Another form of the disease, but the least common of all,
will kill the patient in a short time. Usually 4 or 5 days
after onset. It is the hemorrhagic form in which blood vessels
all over and through the body leak blood. This form of very
highly fatal smallpox is known as “black pox.”
Now one can understand the chances of recovering from the
smallpox infection depends upon the type of infection you
get, how big a dose of the virus you receive and how your
body defenses react to the invasion of the virus. The young
and the old, the malnourished and diseased, are easy victims
for this master killer.
In studying the disease it has been found that smallpox
is not contagious in the victim until the rash appears on
the skin. If vaccination is done on the exposed person in
the first few days, up to five after exposure, the illness
from the smallpox will be reduced or prevented. This is a
plus in controlling an outbreak.
In the late 1700s, practicing in western England was a country
doctor named Edward Jenner. It was he who made one interesting
discovery which led directly to the art of vaccination.
At that time it was common knowledge among country inhabitants
in that area of England, that persons who milked cows and
contracted cowpox from infected cows would not develop smallpox
upon exposure to it.
It was this folk knowledge which prompted a Dorsetshire
farmer named Benjamin Jesty to inoculate his family with
cowpox in 1774. Some soldiers in George Washington’s
Continental Army were reportedly doing the same by passing
a string soaked in cowpox lesions through their skin.
In investigating this rumor or belief among the country
folk, Dr. Jenner collected fluid from cowpox lesions on the
hands of a milk maid named Sarah Nelms. He then transferred
it into abraided skin on the arms of an eight year old boy,
James Phipps. This occurred on May 14, 1796. In a few days
a typical “take” was evident on the young fellow’s
arm. This “take” was the appearance of the papules,
which later turned to pustules, which then became scabs on
the areas where the cowpox material had been placed.
Six weeks later the boy, Phipps, was inoculated with serum
from the papules of a smallpox patient. He did not come down
with the dreaded smallpox. He was immune to it as the country
gossip had predicted. More experiments were performed with
the same results. It was proven that a mild cowpox infection
would produce immunity to the dreaded smallpox.
This procedure of Dr. Jenner was the first recorded vaccination
ever performed to prevent a disease. In this case, when the
cowpox was inoculated into man, the disease which was produced,
was mild, localized to the inoculated area and was called “vaccinia.” Thus
it was Dr. Jenner’s work that led to the term “vaccination” which
came from the Latin word “vacca” which means
cow. For many years the word “vaccination” literally
meant the inoculation of cowpox for the prevention of smallpox
in man.
Today the term vaccination is used to define a procedure
whereby an antigen is injected to produce an immune reaction.
In 1799 Jenner published a paper entitled “An Inquiry
into the Causes and Effects of the Variolae Vaccinae, a Disease
Discovered in some of the Western Counties of England, particularly
Gloucestershire, and known by the Name of Cowpox.” In
this paper he reported it was possible to vaccinate people
with fluids taken from the cowpox lesions, thus protecting
them from smallpox.
An interesting sideline concerning myself is the fact I
have been vaccinated 3 times in my life for smallpox and
none of them “took.” Once, as a child in school
and twice in the army during WWII. Maury Telleen had the
same experience. Both of us can recall having cowpox on our
hands as a result of milking infected cows! — By hand
of course!! We both became immune to small pox and the vaccine
simply did not “take.”
With a good vaccination program in effect, plus the isolation
early on of smallpox patients, the United States and Europe
were declared free of the disease by 1973. Vaccination stopped
in the U.S. in 1972.
The World Health Organization undertook the massive task
of eradicating smallpox from the globe in 1966. In October
of 1975 the last natural occurring case was located in the
person of a 3 year old girl from Bhola Island, Bangladesh,
named Rahima Banu. She survived. In 1977 another case was
found. He was Ali Maou Maalin, a Somali cook. He too survived.
Containing and then eradicating smallpox was a huge undertaking,
but by 1978 the world was free of the disease and in 1980,
the World Health Assembly recommended that all countries
should cease vaccination.
Early on in the 19th century, scholars in both Europe and
America proved that cowpox and smallpox were the same diseases
except they occurred in two species of animals, that is,
cattle and humans. They found that when the smallpox virus
passed into cattle it lost much of its virulence and could
be used as a vaccine. True cowpox therefore is known to be
caused by the smallpox virus. It is also known that this
infection can be transmitted from cow to cow by inoculation
or by recently vaccinated workers.
Since the abolition of smallpox in the world today, the
true cowpox of Jenner’s time has disappeared. It then
seems likely that the bovine disease had its reservoir in
the human population.
The cowpox seen today differs from the older form in that
infection does not occur in those workers who milk and handle
these animals. Vaccinea virus does not prevent the disease
in the cattle and researchers were not successful in transmitting
this disease by inoculation of normal healthy cattle. Thus,
the cowpox of today is not the genuine old cowpox seen long
ago. Today this condition in cattle is referred to as pseudo-cowpox.
Horsepox, also known as contagious pustular stomatitis,
was at one time very common in Europe. It was described by
early Roman writers and by veterinarians of the 1700s. In
the course of the disease, an eruption of pocks or pustules
occurs over any part of the skin or mucous membranes of the
lips or about the nostrils and eyes. However, almost exclusively,
they will erupt and form on the pasterns and fetlocks of
the horse. The condition was often confused with so called “grease
heel” or “grease.”
Jenner studied these conditions in horses and noted that
the disease could be transmitted to cattle and to the stablemen
or people who milked the affected cows. As in the case of
cowpox, these people would become immune to smallpox.
In 1924 a German scientist, Zwick, published his findings
after investigating the disease thoroughly. He concluded
the causative agent to be the virus of vaccinia.
With the demise of smallpox in the world today, the old
time horsepox is also gone. There is no record of this disease
ever occurring in North America.
We know humans are the main host for the smallpox virus.
However, monkeys may become infected with the virus and spread
it to other monkeys and possibly back to man. In Brazil a
smallpox epidemic in the human population was thought to
have started in a group of monkeys. The bodies of the dead
monkeys were examined and found to be covered with smallpox
pustules. According to the literature, an orangutan kept
in a zoo developed smallpox associated with a smallpox outbreak
in Djakarta, Indonesia in 1951.
Since human and sub-human primates live in close contact
with each other, either in the wild or in captivity, one
must be aware that each are very susceptible to the smallpox
virus.
Has Bioterrorism ever been employed in the Western Hemisphere
and in North America? The answer is yes.
The British army used smallpox as a weapon during the French
and Indian war which was fought in 1754 to 1767. Blankets
used by smallpox victims were deliberately given to opposing
American Indian tribes for the express purpose of starting
smallpox outbreaks among them. To the American Indian, smallpox
was extremely deadly. In this case, 50% of the population
of the exposed tribes died of the disease.
The Aztecs and Incas were not necessarily defeated by the
small Spanish armies of the conquistadors which were sent
against them, as by the ravages of smallpox which the Spaniards
inadvertently introduced into their populations. It is estimated
that over half of their people died as a result of the smallpox
epidemics.
Smallpox was introduced by the Spaniards into the Western
hemisphere and by the time the continent was colonized, it
is estimated 6,000,000 of the Indian population died of the
disease.
The Mandans were a proud people that welcomed and gave much
needed support and aid to the Lewis and Clark expedition
during the first winter of their journey in 1804. In 1837,
blankets were given to them containing smallpox virus. A
village of 1600 was reduced to 31 survivors in just 3 weeks.
As the chief lay on his deathbed, it was said that he cursed
the day of the white man’s arrival, and he wished he
had killed them all.
The same can be said for the Blackfoot tribe. They were
a very powerful and proud people that dominated a vast area
including much of Montana, parts of Wyoming, North Dakota
and Canada. They were the American trapper’s worst
enemy. Osborne Russell in his book, The Journal of a Trapper,
describes a village of these people being ravaged by smallpox.
The death toll from the smallpox among our North American
Indians was staggering.
One can but imagine what it was like for these people to
undergo an epidemic of smallpox, especially if it was thrust
upon them with the idea of crippling their society so they
could be managed. Whether it happened accidentally or intentionally,
the result was always the same.
Some facts to remember about smallpox.
- Smallpox in the human and the pox diseases
as seen in monkeys, cattle and horses are caused by the
same or closely
related viruses.
- The smallpox virus, when passed through
cattle and horses, becomes weakened or attenuated. It
is called vaccinea and is used for vaccination against
smallpox.
- The probability of a smallpox attack is very low, however,
if it was to happen, the results would be worldwide and
it
would be devastating.
Therefore,
measures should be undertaken to reduce the risk of an attack and provide
for a defense against it.
- Vaccination will prevent the disease even if
it is administered 5 days after exposure.
- With the possible
exception of monkeys and other subhuman primates, smallpox
is now only hosted by human beings.
- The smallpox virus
will survive for days in clothing and bedding of infected
people.
- The most common route of infection is by inhalation
of the virus during face-to-face contact with a smallpox
victim.
- In the case of an outbreak of smallpox, only
a massive vaccination program would contain it. At the
present
time there are no drugs
which could be
administered to a victim which would destroy the virus and
cure the patient.
|